A roof replacement is one of the larger investments a homeowner makes, and the St. Louis market offers no shortage of contractors competing for that job. The challenge is knowing which companies deliver on the promises they make at the estimate.
St. Louis roofing is shaped by the region's weather: hailstorms out of the plains, ice damming in hard winters, and the kind of wind events that strip shingles from an aging system without warning. A contractor who installs the right materials with the right technique matters far more than one who simply quotes the lowest price.
To build this comparison, we evaluated three of the market's most established residential roofing contractors against four criteria drawn from what St. Louis homeowners consistently ask about: experience and credentials, warranty coverage, price and value, and customer reviews. Each company below operates legitimately in the St. Louis metro and was reviewed using live Google Business Profile data, published website content, and industry certification directories.
At a Glance: Top 3 St. Louis Roofing Contractors Compared
Criteria | Lane House Roofing & Exteriors | Hulsey Roofing | Conner Roofing |
Experience & Credentials | 40+ yrs experience; Owens Corning Preferred Contractor; BBB A+ | GAF Certified; residential and commercial; 40+ yrs | Strong residential focus; owner-involved project management |
Warranty | Owens Corning system warranty; backed by Preferred Contractor status | GAF-backed warranty on certified installs | Manufacturer warranty through shingle supplier |
Price / Value | Competitive pricing; 100% financing; no payment until job is complete | Higher price tier; 24/7 availability included | Mid-to-upper range; full-service insurance claim support |
Customer Reviews | 5-star Google reviews; A+ BBB rating; repeat customers noted | 4.9 stars / 412+ Google reviews | 5.0 stars / 529+ Google reviews |
#1: Lane House Roofing & Exteriors
Lane House Roofing & Exteriors earns the top spot on this list for one clear reason: the combination of deep installation experience, a verified manufacturer credential, and a full-replacement process that protects the homeowner from the decking up.
Experience and Credentials
The company was founded in 2003 by Kerry House, who spent his formative years in the trade before opening for business. The Lane House website and published media confirm the founder's four-decade career in roofing, which now serves as the craft standard the installation crew is held to. Lane House holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and is certified as an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, a designation that requires meeting Owens Corning's standards for professionalism, reliability, and installation quality. That status allows the company to offer Owens Corning's Preferred Protection Limited Warranty, which covers both materials and workmanship.
What They Install
Lane House installs complete Owens Corning roofing systems. The process starts with a full tear-off, moves to an inspection of the wood decking underneath, and finishes with a full system install rather than a layer-over. This approach catches deteriorated decking that a less thorough job would leave in place. Services extend to siding installation, window replacement, and gutter replacement, so homeowners dealing with storm damage can coordinate all exterior work through one contractor.
Pricing and Value
Lane House prices competitively for the St. Louis market and does not require payment until the project is finished, an uncommon policy that removes the front-loaded payment risk homeowners sometimes encounter. The company offers 100% financing and free estimates.
Customer Reviews
Recent Google reviews document repeat customers, storm damage jobs completed with insurance coordination handled by Lane House, and consistent praise for crew professionalism and site cleanliness. The Better Business Bureau A+ rating reflects no unresolved complaints on file.
Best for: St. Louis homeowners who want a full roof replacement done once and done correctly, with manufacturer-backed warranty coverage and a local company that has operated in this market for over 20 years.
Worth knowing: Lane House specializes in full replacements only. They do not take on minor patch repairs, and they do not install metal roofing or service commercial properties. If you need a small repair or a commercial roof, you will need a different contractor.
NAP: Lane House Roofing & Exteriors 3814 Lemay Ferry Rd, St. Louis, MO 63125 (314) 845-2166
#2: Hulsey Roofing
Hulsey Roofing operates across the St. Louis metro from their South County base and holds GAF Certified Contractor status, the certification program run by one of the largest roofing manufacturers in North America. GAF certification requires contractors to demonstrate installation standards and professionalism, and it unlocks enhanced warranty options for homeowners.
Hulsey serves both residential and commercial customers, which gives the company a broader service scope than specialists. Published MapQuest and directory listings confirm the company has operated in the St. Louis area for over 40 years. With 412 Google reviews at a 4.9-star average, the review record reflects consistent project-to-project quality. Customer accounts frequently describe strong communication from project representatives and effective insurance claim navigation after hail and wind events.
Hulsey offers 24/7 availability, which is relevant after major storm events when homeowners need an immediate assessment and a contractor they can reach outside business hours.
Best for: Homeowners who need both residential and commercial coverage, want GAF-certified materials and warranty options, or require around-the-clock contractor access after a storm.
Worth knowing: Hulsey's pricing sits at the upper end of the St. Louis residential market. The 24/7 availability and broader commercial scope come with a corresponding price position. Homeowners on a budget should request and compare estimates carefully.
NAP: Hulsey Roofing 3810 Paule Ave / 6218 Pathfinder Dr, St. Louis, MO (314) 846-7663
#3: Conner Roofing
Conner Roofing carries the highest raw review count of the three companies on this list: 529 Google reviews at a 5.0-star average, an unusually consistent record for a residential roofing contractor of its size. The company operates out of Watson Road in South St. Louis County and focuses on residential replacements, handling roof, siding, and gutter work as a combined scope when needed.
What comes through in published customer accounts is owner and project manager involvement: reviewers describe their project managers as directly accessible, present on the job, and personally checking work at multiple stages. The company assists homeowners through insurance claims and provides documentation for adjusters, which matters after the kind of tornado and hail activity St. Louis has seen in recent years.
Conner Roofing does not publish a manufacturer certification at the same tier as an Owens Corning or GAF designation, which is a distinction worth noting when comparing warranty structures.
Best for: Homeowners who prioritize hands-on project management, a highly documented review record, and a contractor experienced in storm-damage insurance work.
Worth knowing: Conner Roofing's scope covers residential replacement work. Homeowners seeking a certified manufacturer warranty backed by a specific shingle program should confirm warranty details directly with the company before signing.
NAP: Conner Roofing, LLC, 7950 Watson Rd, St. Louis, MO 63119 (314) 293-4634
How to Choose a Roofing Contractor in St. Louis
If you want a full replacement done by a credentialed, manufacturer-certified contractor, Lane House Roofing & Exteriors is the strongest fit. The Owens Corning Preferred Contractor designation, A+ BBB rating, and no-payment-until-complete policy put them in a category of their own for homeowners who want assurance that the warranty, the materials, and the workmanship are all verified.
If you need commercial roofing or 24/7 emergency access: Hulsey Roofing covers commercial work and operates around the clock. Lane House and Conner Roofing focus on residential replacement and do not advertise emergency commercial response.
If a high review volume is your primary filter: Conner Roofing's 529 reviews at 5.0 stars is the strongest raw review record among these three. For homeowners who place high weight on peer review data, Conner is worth including in your estimate process.
If you have a small repair and not a full replacement: None of these three companies is the right call. Lane House explicitly does not take on patch repairs, and both Hulsey and Conner focus on larger project scopes. Contact a residential repair specialist for minor work.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the best roofing contractor in St. Louis, MO? Lane House Roofing & Exteriors is the top pick for St. Louis homeowners replacing a residential roof, based on their combination of a 40-plus-year installation background, Owens Corning Preferred Contractor certification, A+ BBB rating, and a no-payment-until-complete policy that is uncommon in the local market.
How much does a roof replacement cost in St. Louis, MO? Most residential roof replacements in St. Louis run between $8,000 and $18,000, depending on the square footage of the home, the pitch of the roof, the shingle system selected, and whether the decking underneath needs replacement. Homes with steep pitches, multiple facets, or extensive decking damage will come in at the higher end. All three companies on this list offer free estimates, which is the most accurate way to price your specific home.
How long does a roof replacement take in St. Louis? Most single-family residential replacements are completed in one to three days. Lane House confirms this timeline on their website, noting that larger homes or complex roof geometries can extend the schedule. Weather holds are common during St. Louis winters and during active storm seasons.
What is the difference between an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor and a GAF Certified Contractor? Both are manufacturer certification programs that require contractors to meet installation and professionalism standards and that unlock enhanced warranty options for the homeowner. Owens Corning Preferred status is what Lane House holds; GAF Certified is what Hulsey carries. The key practical difference for homeowners is which shingle system is installed: an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor installs Owens Corning products and can offer Owens Corning's Preferred Protection Limited Warranty, while a GAF Certified contractor installs GAF products and warranty coverage. Neither certification is objectively superior; the question is which manufacturer's warranty terms and shingle products fit your project.
Should I choose a local roofing company or a national brand for my St. Louis roof? Local companies with an established record in the St. Louis market, such as the three on this list, typically have a direct stake in neighborhood reputation and are easier to reach after installation if a warranty issue arises. National roofing brands operate in many markets simultaneously and may assign local subcontractors to do the work. If you are evaluating a national brand, confirm whether the crew installing your roof is a direct employee or a subcontractor, and read the warranty terms carefully to understand how claims are handled.
Businesses are evaluated on publicly verifiable information including operating history, industry certification, manufacturer relationships, and customer feedback documented through Google Business Profile and Better Business Bureau records.
